Marxism of the Right

ineptsegue's picture

ineptsegue
(Beingism Founder)

[Editor's note: This is a conservative take on the problems of libertarianism. The author seems to possess the expected conservative points of view on many topics (e.g. socialism, pornography, security) and comes at the issue with a very different framing and a very different set of assumptions from a Beingist (or any progressive). What's interesting is how many commonalities shine through in spite of this.]

Free spirits, the ambitious, ex-socialists, drug users, and sexual eccentrics often find an attractive political philosophy in libertarianism, the idea that individual freedom should be the sole rule of ethics and government. Libertarianism offers its believers a clear conscience to do things society presently restrains, like make more money, have more sex, or take more drugs. It promises a consistent formula for ethics, a rigorous framework for policy analysis, a foundation in American history, and the application of capitalist efficiencies to the whole of society. But while it contains substantial grains of truth, as a whole it is a seductive mistake.

There are many varieties of libertarianism, from natural-law libertarianism (the least crazy) to anarcho-capitalism (the most), and some varieties avoid some of the criticisms below. But many are still subject to most of them, and some of the more successful varieties—I recently heard a respected pundit insist that classical liberalism is libertarianism—enter a gray area where it is not really clear that they are libertarians at all. But because 95 percent of the libertarianism one encounters at cocktail parties, on editorial pages, and on Capitol Hill is a kind of commonplace “street” libertarianism, I decline to allow libertarians the sophistical trick of using a vulgar libertarianism to agitate for what they want by defending a refined version of their doctrine when challenged philosophically. We’ve seen Marxists pull that before.

This is no surprise, as libertarianism is basically the Marxism of the Right. If Marxism is the delusion that one can run society purely on altruism and collectivism, then libertarianism is the mirror-image delusion that one can run it purely on selfishness and individualism. Society in fact requires both individualism and collectivism, both selfishness and altruism, to function. Like Marxism, libertarianism offers the fraudulent intellectual security of a complete a priori account of the political good without the effort of empirical investigation. Like Marxism, it aspires, overtly or covertly, to reduce social life to economics. And like Marxism, it has its historical myths and a genius for making its followers feel like an elect unbound by the moral rules of their society.

For the rest of this article, please go to: http://www.amconmag.com/article/2005/mar/14/00017/

TwitThis
Category:






Comments

Lakia Singletary's picture

Lakia Singletary
(anonymous user)

Here's my first post here

So far beingism.org looks interesting.
If it's not just all bots here, let me know. I'm looking to network
Oh, and yes I'm a real person and I hope are you too. LOL.....I saw a few spam messages

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.